Carbon filters are widely used in various air purifications to capture volatile organic compounds (VOCs), odors, odors, formaldehyde, smoke, etc. Although it excels at targeting a particular type of gas filtration, many users overlook some of its inherent drawbacks, especially when viewed as a "one-stop" solution for indoor air quality.

Here's a detailed look at the key drawbacks of carbon filters, combined with real-world examples to help you make an informed choice.

1. Limited adsorption capacity – easily saturated

Carbon filters work by adsorbing pollutants like formaldehyde. Once the pores are filled with contaminants, the filter function fails, a process known as saturation. Unlike washable and reusable filters, saturated carbon filters (most household models) cannot be cleaned or regenerated and must be replaced with a new one before reuse.

Air Filtration Case：

A South Korean family uses an air purifier with only a carbon filter to remove formaldehyde in their newly renovated living room. Initially, formaldehyde concentrations decrease from 0.12 mg/m³ to 0.08 mg/m³ for the first 2 weeks. In the 3rd week, the formaldehyde concentration rose to 0.11 mg/m³. The test found that the carbon filter was saturated, and the carbon pores were filled with formaldehyde and other VOCs. The family changed the filter 3 times in 2 months to maintain a safe concentration, significantly increasing the long-term cost.

2. Cannot remove particulate matter – such as dust, PM2.5

Carbon filters only target gas and odor adsorption, occasionally some tiny dust, but are completely unable to capture solid particles such as dust, pollen, pet dander, or PM2.5 (fine particulate matter associated with respiratory problems). This is a fatal defect for users in heavily polluted areas or people with allergies.

Air Filtration Case：

An office in South Korea has installed five carbon filter air purifiers designed to combat both haze (high PM2.5) and printer odors. After 1 week, employees still complain of dry and itchy throats and stinging eyes. After air testing, the PM2.5 concentration remained at 75 μg/m³ (much higher than the World Health Organization's standard of 25 μg/m³), and the odor of the printer did decrease. The office then added a HEPA filter (for particulate matter) next to the carbon filter – PM2.5 concentrations dropped to 20 μg/m³ within a few days. ）

3. Selective adsorption – ineffective against some contaminants

Carbon filters Not all gases or VOCs are equally adsorbed by carbon. Small molecules (e.g., methane, carbon monoxide) or highly polar compounds (e.g., ammonia) often penetrate carbon filters without being filtered. This means that even if the carbon filter has some adsorption capacity, it may not be able to handle certain indoor pollutants.

Air Filtration Case：

A restaurant in Seattle, USA, uses carbon filters in kitchen hoods to reduce ammonia and fried food odors in refrigerators. Despite the reduced smell of fried food, employees still feel persistent tingling in their eyes and nose. Ammonia concentrations were found to be 25 ppm (above the 8-hour exposure limit of 25 ppm for the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration). HVAC experts explain: "The adsorption capacity of carbon to ammonia is extremely weak, and a special amine filter is needed instead of an ordinary carbon filter. ”

4. High long--term replacement costs

Due to their susceptibility to saturation, especially in highly polluted environments, carbon filters need to be replaced frequently, much more frequently than HEPA filters or washable filters. Over time, these replacement costs increase, making carbon filters a cost-effective long-term option.

Air Filtration Case：

A pet shelter in Houston, USA, uses 10 carbon filter air purifiers to treat pet odors. The filter costs $25 per unit and needs to be replaced every 4 weeks due to the high odor load. In 1 year, the shelter spent $1500 on carbon filter replacement alone. In contrast, switching to HEPA + carbon composite filters (8 weeks of service life) reduces annual costs in half.

5. Efficiency decreases in high humidity environments

Moisture in the air with high humidity in the environment competes with pollutants for space in the carbon pores. In humid environments (e.g., bathrooms, coastal areas), water molecules preferentially fill carbon pores, leaving less room for VOCs or odors, resulting in a significant decrease in filter efficiency.

Air Filtration Case：

A homeowner in Miami, USA, uses a carbon filter to remove musty odors in his bathroom. During the rainy season (humidity above 80%), the filter does little to alleviate odors. Later testing showed that 60% of the carbon pores were occupied by water, leaving little room to adsorb mold-related VOCs. When the homeowner later added a dehumidifier (which reduced the humidity to 50%), the problem was resolved and the carbon filter returned to its original effectiveness.

Conclusion:

Carbon filters are widely used in the field of purification and have certain value in the treatment of specific gases and odors in air purification, but their disadvantages: easy saturation, inability to remove particulate matter, selective adsorption, high replacement cost and humidity sensitivity, cannot be ignored. Before purchasing, users should use carbon filters in combination with some primary, medium, and high-efficiency filters (such as HEPA filters, cotton filters) to maximize air quality, and replace them regularly according to the environment. Understanding these shortcomings,

It can help you make an informed choice and ensure that your filtration system meets your actual needs.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q1: How long does a carbon filter last?

A1: It depends on usage and contaminant levels. For households, water carbon filters typically last 2–6 months; air carbon filters last 3–6 months. Commercial use may require replacement every 1–4 weeks.

Q2: How to tell if a carbon filter is saturated?

A2: Signs include returning odors (e.g., chlorine smell in water), reduced water flow, or test results showing elevated contaminant levels.

Explore our full range of air filters and find the perfect solution for your needs. If you need assistance purchasing filters or confirming filter size, please call +1 929-204-8922 (9-5 EST Monday-Friday) or email info@gdhaibei.com.